When I think about you I remember the things you said to me as you pushed me away (my first real breakup— the kind that twists your ribs into your spine). But I also remember how you held me that very same night, stroked my hair, captured my tears with your fingerprints and I’m sorry. I love you. I just can’t. I love you, I’m just not happy. Not in love with you.
The day I moved out I watched my stuff loaded into the car and squeezed our cat for what I thought would be the last time. I swear I’ll be back for you. I mumbled into his fur, my fingers pulling at his ears. Your mother helped me move, and for some reason you came alon. As I dropped my stuff off you slid out of the car with me, your arms wrapped around my waist and I looked up and then you kissed me and it was sweet and full of my tears and I knew something was happening and it wasn’t the breakup it was ten minutes ago, it wasn’t the month of hell I endured, sleeping in our bed which was no longer ours, watching you forget me. Somewhere in that kiss you remembered about us.
I remember the first time you kissed me and my legs shook because it was fluid and flawless and maybe it was a bit from the vodka and maybe it was the way your hands landed so softly on my cheek. Someone once told me that a relationship builds foundation around the first kiss. This is the same girl that was nervous because her kisses with her boyfriend were awkward, did she use enough tongue? Too much?
You were the first boy I ever kissed that got it just right.
I remember the second first time you kissed me- a heartbreak later, the tears this time yours, as you held on to every inch of me. The air was full of promises. I miss you. I can’t be without you. I messed up, I’m sorry. I do love you.
I started sleeping at your new place, my legs entwined with yours, still crying into your shoulders because I was so scared that this wasn’t for real, that one day you would remember all the things you hated about me. You held me as safe as you could.
And I was angry with you, then. I had just moved past us, had remembered that there was more than you in the universe, had kissed some boys, had let another one touch me. They weren’t you, but they were the tiny steps I needed to forget you. You made me forget them, and after a while you forgot me.
Our summer of rebuilding love turned into February, and the signs were all there. But how does one go about approaching something they don’t want to admit exists?
I bought a new dress, one with a zipper at the back because you said we’d do something. You’d never taken me out on a date before, we weren’t the dating type, but this time was going to be special. I imagined you taking me out to dinner, maybe giving me a flower or two, taking me home to your place and peeling the back of my dress down, kissing my shoulder blades, telling me I looked beautiful.
I woke up early that morning, baked you cookies in the shape of little hearts, put together a cute little arrangement of thoughtful gifts and waited. And waited. And went to work. And waited. And came home and waited. And cried with the cat. And waited. And then I waited exactly a week to ask.
You don’t love me anymore, do you?
You don’t love me anymore, and I can’t get past it this time. You don’t love me anymore, and my heart sits in my throat all day, because all I ever think about is holding your hand. You don’t love me anymore and last week I bought a queen sized bed so you would stay over more often. I don’t know how to fill the space. You don’t love me anymore and last night I came over to return your stuff because it was haunting me, your toothbrush and boxers sitting in a drawer waiting for you to come back. You don’t love me anymore but you said that one day we could still be friends. You don’t love me anymore, and as I wept in your arms asking you why, why you leaned back and your hoodie rode up and my instinct told me to lay back with you, to slide my hands up your exposed stomach into your chest, to curl around you and keep us safe. You don’t love me anymore and you pulled back as I reached out for you. You don’t love me anymore, and I begged you not to leave me, told you I would be okay just dating, if you would be okay with me loving you enough for the both of us. We could see other people, why didn’t you want to be with me anymore? You don’t need to love me to be with me.
You don’t love me anymore, and you this time you didn’t kiss me goodbye.